Columbia Men’s Newton Ridge Plus II Suede Waterproof Boot: What It’s Good For and Who Should Buy It

The Columbia Men’s Newton Ridge Plus II is a budget mid-hiker built for car camping, easy trails, and overland trips where you’re in and out of the truck more than you’re logging serious mileage. It’s not a technical mountaineering boot, and Columbia never marketed it as one. At $60-90 depending on colorway, it’s the boot you grab when you want dry feet and ankle support without spending Danner or Salomon money.

What This Boot Actually Is

The Newton Ridge Plus II sits in Columbia’s mid-tier hiking line, one step up from their trail shoes and well below their backcountry-specific boots. The suede/mesh upper pairs with Columbia’s proprietary Omni-Tech waterproof membrane, backed by a hydrostatic head rating built for creek crossings and wet grass, not submersion.

Underneath, you get a molded EVA midsole for cushioning and an Omni-Grip rubber outsole with a multi-directional lug pattern. Columbia rates the lugs for wet and dry traction on moderate terrain: gravel roads, packed dirt, light scree. Dry weight runs around 1 lb, 10 oz per boot in a size 10 — light for a mid-hiker, which tells you exactly where Columbia cut corners to hit that price point.

The ankle collar sits mid-height, giving you more lateral support than a trail runner but nowhere near the stiffness of a leather backpacking boot like the Danner Mountain 600. That’s by design. This boot stabilizes you on uneven ground. It doesn’t carry a 50-pound pack.

Check Price on Amazon → (paid link)

Who This Boot Is Genuinely Good For

If your overlanding trips look like base camp setups, short scouting hikes, and moving around wet campsites at 6 a.m., this boot covers you. Columbia built the Omni-Tech membrane for that exact scenario: dew-soaked grass, muddy fire roads, a shallow crossing to grab firewood.

It’s also a smart pick for guys who want one boot that goes from the trailhead parking lot to a gear store to a barbecue without looking like a tactical operator showed up. The suede upper reads casual. You can wear these into REI or a diner and nobody’s asking if you just came off a summit.

Weekend car campers and overlanders running established routes — think Moab’s paved-adjacent BLM land or a Forest Service road in the Ozarks — get real value here. You’re not scrambling talus fields. You’re setting up a tent, walking to a viewpoint, and keeping your feet dry doing it.

Budget matters too. If you’re outfitting a family of four for a first overland trip and don’t want to drop $180 per pair on boots before you know if anyone actually likes camping, the Newton Ridge Plus II lets you test the waters without blowing the gear budget.

Who Should Skip It

If you’re running technical trails with loose rock, exposed scrambling, or steep grades under a loaded pack, look elsewhere. The EVA midsole doesn’t give you the torsional rigidity you need when you’re placing your foot on an angled rock face and trusting the boot not to roll under you.

Backpackers logging 8+ miles a day with 30+ pounds on their back will outgrow this boot fast. I’ve guided plenty of trips where a boot like this shows up on someone’s feet day one and their ankles are done by day three. GearJunkie’s testers flag the same problem in their reviews: fine for day hikes, questionable once you add weight and mileage.

Anyone doing serious mud or snow work needs more boot. The ankle height won’t keep slop out of your socks once you’re past a few inches of standing water, and the lug depth isn’t aggressive enough for real mud season traction. For that, get the Merrell Moab 3 Mid or something built specifically for wet, technical ground.

Check Price on Amazon → (paid link)

And if you’re hard on gear — bushwhacking off-trail, dragging boots through scree fields, doing real overland recovery work in the mud — the suede upper and lighter-duty construction won’t hold up as long as a full-grain leather boot. This is a boot built for moderate use. Not abuse.

Realistic Expectations

Break-in time is minimal. In my experience, an hour or two of walking is all it takes before this boot stops feeling stiff, which beats the 20-30 miles you’ll spend breaking in a stiffer leather boot. That’s a real advantage if you buy boots on Tuesday and want them comfortable by the weekend.

The waterproofing works well out of the box but fades with use, same as any DWR-treated membrane boot. Expect a noticeable drop in performance after 6-12 months of regular wear unless you’re reapplying treatment. Nikwax Fabric & Leather Proof runs about $12 and pushes that window out to closer to 18 months if you apply it every season.

Check Price on Amazon → (paid link)

Light-to-moderate use gets you 1-2 years of solid service. That tracks with what I’ve seen in the field and what shows up across owner reports. Push these hard — daily wear, rough terrain, constant water exposure — and the soles start separating or the upper wears through in 6-8 months. That’s typical for a boot at this price. Columbia doesn’t pretend otherwise. You’re trading longevity for cost and comfort out of the box.

Sizing runs true. Go a half-size up if you’re wearing thicker hiking socks. A pair of Darn Tough Hiker Socks in merino wool changes the fit and warmth in cooler weather. Factor that into your order before you commit to a size.

The Verdict

The Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II earns its spot as a budget-friendly, genuinely waterproof mid-hiker for casual overlanding and car camping. It’s not trying to be a $200 backpacking boot, and it shouldn’t be judged against one. For dry feet on moderate terrain, a fast break-in, and all-day comfort around camp, it delivers exactly what Columbia promises.

Buy this if you’re outfitting for weekend trips, established roads, and day hikes where support needs are moderate. Skip it if you’re logging serious backcountry miles with a loaded pack or working wet, technical terrain regularly. Know the tradeoff going in: light weight and easy break-in against long-term durability. This boot earns its price tag without excuses.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product links on this page are affiliate links — if you click and buy, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.